This Can’t Be A Coincidence: People Associate “Notre Dame Football” With “Annoying”

Way back in April, I wrote a post called “The Most Annoying Traits of Football Fans” in which I described behaviors that make the rest of the football-watching world cringe when they see them because they make the rest of us look bad.  Some of the things I talked about in the post were:

  • Overuse of the phrase “Nobody gave us a chance”
  • Being disappointed or bragging about events that happened before you were born
  • Justifying a loss based on “We let them win” logic
  • The use of (insert fanbase or mascot)-nation
  • Being a team’s apologist
  • Not acknowledging any other team’s success
  • “Fire the coach” guy

And most of all:

  • Deifying or idolizing teams, players, coaches, GM’s, or owners

On Sunday (November 25th), I got more hits for that particular article than I ever had in a single day since it was posted.  This was the day after Notre Dame beat Southern Cal 22-13.

I find it very hard to believe that those two happenings are a coincidence.  Notre Dame Football falls into the same category as the New York Yankees, Dallas Cowboys, and LA Lakers, Bill O’Reilly, and Howard Stern: everybody has an opinion about them.  This year’s BCS National Title game is a dream-scenario for the media in this country because both the fans and the dissenters are going to tune in to anything that has “Notre Dame” in the headline unlike if it were any other college football team in the country.

So Domers, just in case you were wondering, here is why the rest of the college football world may find you annoying.

Since 1993, the Irish fanbase has been quieted and humbled somewhat due to their inability to win a bowl game for thirteen years (1994-2006 seasons), a revolving door for the Head Coach position, losing to opponents at home that would not even be an afterthought during Notre Dame’s “glory days” (Syracuse, Navy, Tulsa, South Florida, Stanford, UConn, Pitt, Air Force, Purdue, Boston College, and Navy*) and the George O’Leary scandal.

For the next 43 days (and the entire offseason if Notre Dame wins), all of that will go out the window.  Anybody who even has the most tertiary connection to Notre Dame will claim to be a lifelong Fighting Irish fan.

At the root of it, I think that’s why people find the Notre Dame Fighting Irish to be annoying.  No other school in the country can call on that many people for support.  If Southern Cal goes to the BCS National Championship, the entire state of California is not rooting for them.  People who watch their favorite team or school for twelve to fourteen Saturdays a year can’t stand it when somebody who never talks about college football (or any other sport for that matter), starts watching and rooting for a team when they get close, or only when things are going well. That just reminds us of the worst behavior of politicians.

Other schools don’t get a special exemption from conference championship games.  If Texas were to leave the Big 12 for whatever reason and become an independent, do you think the BCS would make a special exception for them and invite Texas’ Athletic Director to the discussion just because they are Texas?  I highly doubt it.  Giving Notre Dame the privilege of being able to call the shots is like having the 106-year-old town founder approve any city ordinance.

Other schools don’t get movies made about their walk-ons.  At any other school, the story (or more truthfully, myth) would rise to “campus legend” status, but not get its own movie, and it shouldn’t.

That’s another thing that irks people about Notre Dame.  Their major contributions to college football were so far in the past that nobody alive today can remember them first-hand, but the rest of the football world is expected to bow to them just because they are Notre Dame.

Case in point: Who and when was the last Notre Dame Heisman Trophy winner?  That one’s easy; Tim Brown in 1987.  What about before that?  John Huarte in 1964.  The Irish had two Heisman winners in the 50’s (Paul Hornung and Johnny Lattner), and three in the 40’s (Angelo Bertelli, Johnny Lujak, and Leon Hart).  So basically, any casual fan would have a hard time remembering or visualizing a single play that six of their seven Heisman Trophy winners made because it happened over fifty years ago, and in an era when only two to three games were televised a week (and less than that in the 40’s; that was still the era of the radio). Just think, in the 25 years since Notre Dame last won a Heisman Trophy, players from schools such as Houston, Oklahoma State, Baylor, Auburn, Wisconsin, BYU, and Colorado have all won one.  And none of those schools have the nationwide following Notre Dame does.

It’s not just the Heisman where Notre Dame is more legend that reality.  Think of all the stories of Notre Dame lore.  Win One For the Gipper was over eighty years ago and the term is now used sarcastically.  The Four Horsemen was a publicity stunt and a colorfully written newspaper article perpetuated by Grantland Rice.  Two of their most famous games, 1946 vs. Army and 1966 vs. Michigan State, were a scoreless tie and a 10-10 tie in which Notre Dame played most of the game not to lose (yes, I am aware that their starting quarterback was out of the game and had one game left against USC, but still no excuses).  If either of these games were re-played on ESPN Classic or some other venue today, they would be viewed as being on the same level of boring as last year’s LSU/Alabama regular season game.  Arguably their greatest win of the last thirty years (vs. Florida State in 1993, #1 vs. #2) was effectively nullified the next week at home by an inferior opponent.    You can’t live off of ghosts of the past forever, but Notre Dame certainly tries.

People don’t like it when you try to get special treatment, but can’t answer the question, “What have you done for me lately?”.

I’ve only scratched the surface of why people may find Notre Dame annoying.  I find it very interesting and not coincidental whatsoever that a blog post I wrote over six months ago racked up that many hits on that day.  Can we keep one thing in mind over the next six weeks?  Whoever has the better football team will win this year’s BCS National Championship; not the team with the more storied tradition.

*That isn’t a typo; It just feels really good to write that Notre Dame has had a really hard time beating a service academy in recent years (yes, I’m aware that Notre Dame won “at” Navy this year).


9 Responses to This Can’t Be A Coincidence: People Associate “Notre Dame Football” With “Annoying”

  1. As an Aggie, I can somewhat understand the following that Notre Dame has. The fact that they are independent also adds to the “everyone roots for Notre Dame” aura because they are not beholden to any conference. I have never understood the special exemption, but I suppose it all boils down to money.

  2. radarluvsthetandy says:

    Radar loves the tandy! Go ND! The school where players get a real degree!

  3. radarluvsthetandy says:

    …and Charlie Weis kept a pillow in his pants!

I do appreciate other viewpoints, so please comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: